I have a letter from her
When she worked for the Woman's Realm
And all the things she promised me
She promised herself as wellShe said, "I want my freedom"
And ran off along the beach
It's hard to love a girl so near
Yet so far out of the reach
Yet so far out of reachShe came back when the tide came in
And introduced her friend to me
She said, "Don't ring while he is here"
And gave me back my poetryShe expected me to understand
As she's always done this before
And now she asks me
"Why don't you send me poems anymore
Send me poems anymore?"As she steals more than she buys
You can see it in her eyes
She'll come back as soon as she's ready
She's a bad pennyBut she comes back and asks me
To sing all her favorite songs
As if she's never been away
As if she's done nothing wrongBut I've come to the conclusion
That she doesn't realize a thing
And she probably still thinks I love her
And she doesn't know that it's a sin
She doesn't know that it's a sinAs she steals more than she buys
You can see it in her eyes
She'll come back as soon as she's ready
She's a bad pennyShe'll come back as soon as she's ready
She's a bad penny
She'll come back as soon as she's ready
She's a bad penny