Let me start by sayin' I still love you
But when you were gone I met somebody
I don't know, I don't know what to do
Which one?I never meant to be in the wrong
Though I must admit that she had me gone
Caught up in believing that she was the one
I created a stormLet me explain what's goin' on
She kept me sane when you were gone
I never knew all the things she would do
They remind me of youI know I love her but I gotta be sure
She reminds me of the one I adore
I don't wanna be confused anymore, I gotta pick one
Which one? Which one?I know this is strange but let me go on
It's like the more that she stayed the more she belonged
Wanted to escape but it kept getting stronger and stronger
I couldn't leave her aloneWhen I met her things suddenly changed
Now I'm stuck in the middle tryin' to find, find my way
I'm wonderin' if this is all a mistake
Nothing will ever be the sameI know I love her but I gotta be sure
She reminds me of the one I adore
I don't wanna be confused anymore, I gotta pick one
Which one? Which one?Baby, I'm in love
I'm in love with her too
I know that it seems unfair
And then what can I do?I know I love her but I gotta be sure
She reminds me of the one I adore
I don't wanna be confused anymore, I gotta pick one
Which one? Which one?It wasn't supposed to be like this
I mean it was one kiss and then we made love
I'm sorry, I gotta pick one
Which one?I know I love her but I gotta be sure
She reminds me of the one I adore
I don't wanna be confused anymore, I gotta pick one
Which one? Which one?I know I love her
She reminds me
I don't wanna be confused anymore, I gotta pick one
Which one? Which one?