Theme Song for a New Brunswick Basement Show Lyrics

Could it be a stranger night?
The basements filled with kids.
I don't know.
Not beautiful like your songs,
but all awkward and alone and don't belong.
I saw a vacant seat.
I sat down next to you.
I thought of all the boys that wanted to.
I laughed out loud.
Do you hate this band too?
I smiled a nervous smile,
but I warmed up and acted cool standing by the stove.
And your eyes made it strange and I felt out of place.
Wondering if you... if you could take her place.
You can't be sly.
You can't forget her.
You don't ask why.
You can't forget her.

Give up.
What hope do you have to save her?
Give up.
What hope do you have to save her?